Monday, January 31, 2011

Delhi girls are easy?

A few weeks ago, I was talking to an acquaintance about a news item about a young girl who'd been sexually abused by her local guardian. Blackmailed and abused for several months, she finally picked up the courage to file a case against him.


TV news channels immediately scented a story and convinced her to tell her story. While they did blur her face (legal requirements and all), one of the channels focussed repeatedly and unnecessarily on Page 1 of her case affidavit which gave her real name, father's name and address.

I was really mad and being very vocal about this completely unethical behaviour, when suddenly she said – remember this is a jeans-clad, Gucci-sporting 21st century woman speaking - “Oh, You can't trust these Delhi girls, yaar! They're easy! She must have had her fun from it! You make everything into a woman's issue. It's passé to be feminist now!” And she giggled.

Delhi girls are easy? Passé to be feminist? A woman's issue? How can anyone be so insensitive? I completely acknowledge that there are thousands of women in this country who have enjoyed nothing but kindness and protection from their menfolk. Fathers, uncles, brothers, sons, husbands have always supported and guided them. They have kept them away from petty annoyances and raised them to be a league apart. And just because they live like that, how can they deny the existence of someone like that girl on TV?

Don't they realise that in this very nation where they live like princesses, hundreds of women are burnt for dowry? Do they deny the women who submit to sexual excesses and put themselves at risk of domestic violence and abuse by spouses who were supposed to love and protect them? Do they deny the thousands of little girls in our country who don't get enough to eat or don't go to school because of their gender?

Can they deny all the little babies that were thrown in dustbins or poisoned merely because they were female? Do they deny all the young girls working in their very own homes and factories? Do they deny bonded labour? Do they deny trafficking in children? When they attack women who talk about serious issues and kick them to the sidelines, do they realise that there, but for the grace of God, might be themselves?

It is a pathetic state of affairs and it saddens me. Not that I have been labelled and sidelined, but that the issues have been denied and sidetracked. Unlike the American women all of whom were denied suffrage and fought for the vote, our country has a few privileged who have most of the say. Those who have don't want to fight for the have nots. No one wants to sully their hands in feminism.

The system is too dirty to clean up. They know they have to play dumb to keep their own situations safe. Everywhere I see a false sense of well-being. People who are afraid to protest because they don't want to face the discrimination themselves. They so want to be 'in' that they completely forget that so many, so many of their sisterhood is very much 'out of it.'

Every woman who overworks and underpays her maid or who employs a little child to look after her children is a criminal. Every woman who looks the other way while lower wages are paid to women in her factory or company for the same work that male workers get paid more for is a callous bitch. Apathy I have met before. But denial? That is really taking it too far.

12 comments:

aparna said...

Very sad to hear, but not at all unusual. I have heard of women being blamed for everything including:

* being harassed (too provocative)
* not being harassed (too ugly)
* getting married too late (burden on parents)
* getting married too early (too horny)
* not getting pregnant soon enough (disregards parents' desire for grandchild)
* getting pregnant but having a miscarriage (what did she do to bring it on?)
* not talking enough (if she doesn't protest, she deserves it)
* talking too much (she asked for attention)

Sigh.

starry eyed said...

How the privilege makes us think we're immune to these issues. Unbelievable.

You're right. I have so many friends busy protecting their menfolk, because they don't want to see how the system is still victimising all of us.

Careless Chronicles said...

@aparna: Somehow, it's true that everything ends up being the woman's fault. Reminds me of a quote which said something like "I had to become a feminist as an alternative to living as a masochist."
@starry-eyed: I think for many women feminism is dirty and associated with cigarette smoking, free love advocating, child neglecting, beer imbibing, cuckolding, home breaking and disco dancing. All major crimes in our pativrata society.

Phoenixritu said...

Should ask such a person if she ever "had her fun" and then raised a hue and cry! Sheesh

Careless Chronicles said...

@PhoenixRitu: I was actually flabbergasted and dumbstruck. Never thought of asking anything. And she's from Bombay. Her boyfriend, who's from Delhi, had educated her on this... :)

shilpa said...

Wow that was a very sad thing to hear, that too coming from a woman! Having said that, I will say that I have heard similar things from people. One co-worker once told me he thought Hyderabad girls are wily and 'use' men, this in front of me, a Hyderabadi! Needless to say I never talked to him again. How can being raped be a girl's fault?

CLS said...

Sometimes, the best I can do is to restrain myself from slapping someone. Is that how you felt?

For some people, I think it's about more than just playing safe. Sex is still a dirty word for us and Indian women have been so programmed to pretend it does not exist (think Sanskari Bahu) that most people don't know how to react when they hear anything to do with it.

Sadly, even the abuser must have felt that the girl was "having her fun from it". It's sickening to imagine but at some level, it's true.

eeprikka said...

I still remember an incident at my dentist's. He was chitty chatting with me (which is really the last thing a dentist should do with their patients) and I mentioned that I was studying in Delhi..
His next question was - oh so do you know of any of those girls who sleep around for money? It must be very common in Delhi no?
He was referring to an India Today article about the issue, all the same I was appalled and disgusted that he was asking me such a question..

Anonymous said...

Discrimination is everywhere not just in India. Worse thing is you have to play dumb if you want to be safe. It curdles my blood , but thats how it is. Happened recently to me , when I was told that I will be thrown out of university if I do not join my class for trip of a religious place (I am a non religious person and didn't want to join). And this happened in a very "secular" country in the supposedly civilized western country!

Careless Chronicles said...

@ Shilpa: I have no idea how some people can be so opinionated and certain of their infallibility. And it is only prejudiced people who feel compelled to enlighten others. Why is the voice of tolerance and sanity always silent?
@CLS: Like I said I was dumbstruck. I felt claustrophoibic and wanted to get away quick. And sorry about this generalisation, but most Indian men I know have always been very optimistic about their overall capacity to give pleasure.
@eeprikka: I blogged about the effect such generalisation by the media has in this post. I think talking about sex with people of the opposite sex is one of the mating displays that many guys use. I have no idea why they think it works.
@Anonymous: If only the legal system were quick enough to be of some use to anyone seeking redress, we'd have less people getting away with such remarks.

Purva said...

CC i strongly believe that its Delhi Men to be blamed rather than Delhi girls...
yeah yeah men would be men but i have felt it myself, i have been on my own post school, have travelled to diff placed within india... but Delhi makes me alert and does not let me forget that i am a girl..
You go to villages in Haryana where young men will sit with Old folks and make fun of every female in the village & pass leud comments so its so they have lived their lives thinking its right and fair and if they are talking its because of the females dressing sense/ chatter/ etc etc,....
you go to bangalore/ Pune/ Mumbai you can roam around much safely at week hours as well. nobody would make a pass on you or want to grab you just because you are standing on the road waiting for a cab...so does Delhi girl changes when she goes to these places

Careless Chronicles said...

@ Purva: I know. Some cities feel so much safer than others. I do want to write a post on this. :)